24/7 breakdown support across the Riverina0427 997 730[email protected]

Home / Irrigation pump control / Pump starter guide

Guide · Irrigation pumps

DOL, soft starter or VSD: how to choose a starter for an irrigation pump

What each starter does to the motor, the pipeline and the power supply, and a plain way to pick the right one for your pump.

Every irrigation pump needs something to start and stop its motor. The choice between a direct-on-line starter, a soft starter and a variable speed drive affects your power bill, how long the pump and pipework last, and whether the electricity distributor will let you connect the pump at all. This guide explains the options in plain terms, so you can have a better conversation with your electrician or pump supplier.

The short answer

  • Direct-on-line (DOL): small motors on a strong supply, where the pump always runs flat out
  • Soft starter: larger fixed-speed pumps, where starts and stops need to be gentle on the supply and the pipeline
  • Variable speed drive (VSD): where demand changes, where you want to hold a pressure or flow, or where the supply is weak

The starter is only one part of an irrigation pump controller. The same board also holds the motor protection, the pressure, flow or level control and any remote monitoring. More on that below.

Automated river pump control board built by AMC, installed in a pump shed

What happens when a pump motor starts

A standard induction motor switched straight onto the supply draws about six to eight times its full-load current for the few seconds it takes to reach speed. That surge pulls the supply voltage down, so lights dim and other equipment can trip. The sudden torque also loads the shaft, coupling and pump. In the pipeline, a fast start or stop changes the water's speed quickly, which causes the pressure surges known as water hammer.

Electricity distributors limit starting current for this reason. In NSW, the Service and Installation Rules say a motor's starting current must not pull the voltage at the connection point down by more than 5% for more than 20 milliseconds. They also set a starting current limit for three-phase motors at non-domestic sites: 3.3 amps for each kilowatt of motor rating, plus 53 amps (clause 1.17.2.4 and Table 1-3 of the April 2026 edition). For a 30 kW pump that works out to about 152 A. Started direct-on-line, the same motor would typically draw 350 A or more. So larger pumps need a reduced-current starter, or the distributor's agreement, before they are connected.

The options compared

DOLStar-deltaSoft starterVSD
Starting current (typical)6 to 8 times full loadAbout a third of DOLAbout 3 to 4 times full load, adjustableAt or below full load
Controlled stopNoNoYes, with pump controlYes
Speed control while runningNoNoNoYes
Saves energy when demand variesNoNoNoYes
Up-front costLowestLowMediumHighest
Best suited toSmall pumps on a strong supplyOlder boards with six-terminal motorsLarger pumps at one fixed dutyChanging demand, pressure or flow control, weak supplies

Direct-on-line (DOL)

A DOL starter is a contactor and an overload relay. It is cheap, simple and reliable, with very little to go wrong. The drawbacks are the full starting surge and the abrupt start and stop. DOL suits small pumps on a solid supply where the pump runs at one duty.

Star-delta

Star-delta is an older way to cut the starting surge. The motor starts with its windings connected in star, which reduces starting current and starting torque to about a third, then switches to delta to run. It needs a six-terminal motor and three contactors, the changeover causes a second current spike, and it does nothing for stopping. Soft starters have replaced it on most new pump boards.

Soft starter

A soft starter ramps the motor voltage up over a few seconds, which limits the starting current and brings the pump up to speed smoothly. Most then close a bypass contactor, so at full speed the motor runs straight from the supply with almost no loss. A soft starter with a pump control function can also ramp the pump down, which lets the check valve close gently and reduces water hammer.

What a soft starter can't do is change the running speed. The pump runs flat out, and any flow control is done by throttling a valve or cycling the pump on and off. Motor torque also falls with the square of the voltage, so the ramp has to be set up for the pump. This matters most on submersible bore pumps, which need to get up to speed quickly.

Need help with this at your plant? Send us the scope, drawings or a few photos and an engineer will reply within one business day.

Variable speed drive (VSD)

A VSD, also called a VFD or inverter, changes the frequency of the supply to the motor, so it controls the speed all the time and not just at the start. With a pressure or flow sensor it holds a setpoint as valves, sprinklers and blocks open and close. Starting current is at or below full-load current, and both the start and the stop are fully controlled.

The energy case comes from the pump affinity laws. Flow changes in proportion to speed, pressure with the square of speed, and power with the cube of speed. A pump slowed to 80% speed needs roughly half the power. The real saving is smaller where most of the pump's work is lifting water up a fixed height, such as a deep bore or a high river bank, because the pump still has to make that pressure before any water moves. The pump curve and the system curve should be checked before a drive is bought on energy savings alone.

A drive is not free to run. It loses a few per cent of the power as heat, so a pump that really does run at full speed all the time will use slightly more power on a VSD than on a bypassed soft starter.

What to check before fitting a VSD

  • Heat and dust: a drive needs cooling air and a clean enclosure. A pump shed in a Riverina summer needs a board that is properly ventilated or cooled
  • Harmonics: drives draw a distorted current. The NSW rules treat frequency converters as equipment that must meet the harmonic limits in the AS/NZS 61000.3 series, and larger drives may need reactors or filters
  • Cable length to the motor: long motor cables, common on bore pumps, cause voltage peaks at the motor terminals. An output filter and a motor suited to drive duty protect the windings
  • Minimum speed: submersible motors need enough speed for bearing lubrication and enough flow past the motor for cooling. Motor manufacturers commonly set a minimum of about 30 Hz and a fast ramp up to it. Follow the limits for your motor
  • Interference: screened motor cable and correct earthing stop the drive upsetting sensors, telemetry and radio links
  • What if it fails: if the pump is critical in the middle of summer, plan for a bypass starter or a spare drive

Weak supplies, SWER lines and generators

Many pump sites sit at the end of a long rural power line. A weak supply makes the starting surge worse, so a soft starter or a VSD is often the only way to run a larger motor at all. On single-phase and SWER supplies, some VSDs can run a three-phase motor from a single-phase input, within what the line can deliver and with the drive sized for the job. On a generator, a soft starter or VSD lets a smaller set start the pump, but the generator and the drive have to be matched.

In every case, talk to the electricity distributor early. For most of regional NSW, including the Riverina, that is Essential Energy.

A simple way to choose

  1. Does demand change? If you water blocks of different sizes, run a varying number of outlets or need steady pressure, a VSD usually earns its keep.
  2. Is it one fixed duty? If the pump fills a channel or dam at one flow, a soft starter, or DOL for a small motor, is simpler and cheaper.
  3. How big is the motor and how strong is the supply? Check the starting current against the distributor's limit before you buy anything.
  4. How long is the pipeline? Long rising mains and lines with check valves benefit from a controlled stop.
  5. What else do you want from it? Remote start, pressure control, dry-run protection and run records. A VSD brings some of these with it. With a soft starter they are added in the control board.
  6. What does it cost over ten years? Count power, repairs and call-outs, not just the price on day one.

Protection matters as much as the starter

Whatever starts the motor, the pump still needs protecting from running dry, pumping against a closed valve, losing a phase and lightning surges on the line. A good pump board includes overload and phase-failure protection, dry-run or low-flow protection, pressure or level control and surge protection, and it tells you when something trips instead of leaving you to find out at the next watering.

How AMC helps

AMC designs and builds irrigation pump control boards in our Griffith workshop, with DOL starters, soft starters or VSDs to suit the pump, plus pressure, flow and level control, telemetry and remote monitoring from your phone. We look at the pump, the supply and how you water before we recommend anything. On one river pump project we replaced a manually run pump with an automated system with a VSD and remote control, with up to 30% less water wasted.

This guide is general information. Starter and drive selection depends on the pump, motor, pipework and supply at your site, and the installation must comply with AS/NZS 3000 and your electricity distributor's rules. Written by the AMC Electrical & Automation engineering team in Griffith, NSW. Last checked November 2026.

FAQs

Common questions about pump starters and drives

Do I need a VSD or a soft starter for my irrigation pump?

If the pump always runs at one duty, a soft starter is usually enough: it limits the starting current and can stop the pump gently. If demand changes, or you want to hold a pressure or flow, a VSD is the better choice because it controls speed all the time.

Will a VSD cut my pump's power bill?

It can, if the pump spends much of its time at less than full flow. Power falls with the cube of speed, so a pump at 80% speed uses roughly half the power. The saving is smaller where most of the head is static lift, and there is no saving on a pump that has to run at full speed all the time.

Does a soft starter save energy?

Not while the pump is running. A soft starter only controls the start and the stop. Once the pump is at speed the motor runs at full voltage and full speed, the same as direct-on-line.

Can I put a VSD on a bore pump?

Yes, with care. Submersible motors need a minimum speed for bearing lubrication and cooling flow, commonly about 30 Hz, and a fast ramp up to that speed. Long cable runs down the bore usually need an output filter. Check the motor manufacturer's limits.

Why do the lights dim or the supply trip when my pump starts?

A motor started direct-on-line draws six to eight times its normal current for a few seconds, which pulls the voltage down, especially at the end of a long rural line. A soft starter or VSD reduces that surge.

Can a VSD run a three-phase pump from single-phase power?

Some can. The drive has to be designed or sized for a single-phase input, and the supply still has to deliver the power the pump needs. It is worth checking with your electricity distributor what the line can support.

Does a VSD or soft starter stop water hammer?

A controlled ramp up and ramp down reduces the water hammer caused by normal starts and stops. It can't help when the power fails and the pump stops suddenly, so long pipelines may still need surge protection in the pipework.

Next step

Got a plant, machine or board that needs sorting?

Send us the scope, drawings or a few photos. An engineer reads every request and comes back within one business day with next steps and a clear, upfront price.

Project engineer or OEM? Send a P&ID, equipment list or scope for a budget price.

Call nowEmailGet a quote